Wednesday, 9 December 2020

Trump Pressure by Foxymoron

The last week has seen further pressure on Trump to concede, with more and more of the GOP deserting him. On a hand today, the run of the trumps exerted a similar amount of pressure.

Some players think there is a gap between a weak two and a one-level opening bid. I would also prefer to pass with a flawed weak two, and I would not open a weak two with more than one of the following flaws (although third in hand I would relax the requirements):

a) Two aces
b) A side 4-card major
c) More than half my points outside the suit
d) A void
e) A suit worse than QJTxxx
f) Ten or more HCPs

I would have opened 2S on Vampyr's hand below, but it is close. It only fails on rule (c) and only just. I don't mind pass, and I don't mind 1S. It meets the rule of 18 in that the points plus the two longest suits total 18 or more.

West expressed her hand quite well, by jumping to 3S over the reverse of 2D. What could that be other than a good weak two with a flaw or two? Ken Rolph was not going to pussyfoot around and jumped to 6S. A couple of well-placed kings is about all he needed and the good slam was reached. The cold slam in fact.

But it is matchpoints and there might be a bonus for 13 tricks. Indeed, there was as 6S= only gets 65% while 6S+1 is over 90%. North leads a passive heart and you ruff a heart, draw a trump, play the ace of diamonds and ruff a diamond and ruff another heart. Now you ruff a diamond and the king does not fall. Time to broach the clubs and a club to the queen holds. Now run all the trumps. If North has the king of diamonds and the king of clubs he will be squeezed. As it happens, the king of clubs is doubleton, so good technique does not get an extra reward, but +1010 does get almost all the matchpoints.


Vampyr played the slightly inferior line of playing to pin the doubleton ten of  clubs, so NS escaped gratefully with a 35% board. This was still enough for Vampyr and KenRolph to win the event by less than 1%.

Thursday, 3 December 2020

Elimination by Foxymoron


Elimination in bridge has a couple of possible meanings. In one sense it is removing the opponent's safe exit cards and then throwing him or her in to concede a ruff and discard or lead into a tenace. The second meaning is eliminating possible layouts and finding the only one that is possible. Both were applicable on the deal below:


Vampyr's 4D bid was a bit aggressive, but partner rated to have a good hand vulnerable, and North chose 4H. East made the normal lead of the three of diamonds and West played the nine. North won with the ace, crossed to the queen of spades, and played a heart. West tried a deceptive king, but Michael brushed that aside, and won, cashed the queen of hearts, and played three more rounds of spades ending in dummy. West discarded the four of diamonds, current count, showing an even number originally, and then a diamond and a club. Now declarer led a club off dummy to the nine. West should put in the ten, but not the king, although it should not matter. Now East won with the jack of clubs, cashed the jack of hearts and continued fatally with the ace of clubs after which he was endplayed, forced to concede a ruff and discard. The winning defence was to underlead the ace of clubs and declarer has to lose a diamond trick.

How can East figure this out? Well, West has one spade and two hearts for sure. He might have seven diamonds, but the carding in diamonds says that is not the case. North might have Kx of clubs, in which case partner should have put in his highest club on the first round of the suit. Also, underleading the ace of clubs does not cost at all, as cashing the ace of clubs would leave you endplayed. So, the only possible remaining layout is for North to have two small clubs. So, you should underlead the ace of clubs and partner will exit with a diamond for one off. A complete top-to-bottom swing on one card, a little unluckily.

Wednesday, 2 December 2020

Knavery by Foxymoron

    
The Knave of Hearts. Illustration by W.W. Denslow.

The Knave of Hearts
 He stole those tarts,
And took them clean away

This extract of a rhyme by an anonymous author first appeared in the European Magazine in April 1782. There are more verses than are normally published, but I guess what the King of Spades did with the maids has been deemed unsuitable for the target audience. Ryan Stephenson used the jack of hearts well on this hand:


West opened a multi and Ryan made a practical bid of 2NT on the South hand. Many play here that double is either hearts or not hearts, which is a bit Humpty Dumpty I know (wrong nursery rhyme - Ed.). Andy Clery had an easy raise to game as, even opposite South's maximum, slam is unlikely. West led the king of hearts, but Ryan ducked in both hands. West could do no more than play a second heart, but Ryan ran his eight minor suit winners and West was strip-squeezed down to the queen of hearts and Kx of spades. Ryan exited with the knave of hearts in the ending and completed a well-earned +660.

The knave of hearts was key to the following hand as well, and Ryan tested declarer's technique with the best defence:


The above auction was fairly common last night, although some Souths passed (only six of them, partner). North avoided the king of hearts lead, which would have led to the contract making immediately as the dreaded jack of hearts pops up in dummy. Andy Clery dutifully led his partner's suit and Ryan won and switched to the ten of hearts. It looks normal to duck that now, but Frances Loughridge, perhaps fearing a singleton heart with South, won with the ace and should now ruff a club, draw a round of trumps, ruff the last club and draw the final round of trumps. Now she can lead towards the jack of hearts. North can take his two heart winners but is then endplayed. If South does have a high heart, nothing is lost as there is still the diamond finesse. Instead she took the diamond finesse and North cashed out for one off. These two hands helped Ryan and Andy to a narrow first place less than 1% clear of the field.

There were quite a few points of interest on this hand. Gerry Weston, North, led a passive trump as his partner, Paul Thornton, had "meekly" passed as South. Now declarer drew trumps and played ace and another diamond. North needed to duck this, but when he won that was 11 tricks and a near bottom;  this misdefence was also found by Kevin Robins in the North seat. It was even tougher for Nigel Stuttard, North, when East opened a Lucas Two Spades and was raised to game. South led a diamond and now. when declarer played low from dummy, he needed to put in the ten to hold declarer to ten tricks.

On a heart lead by South, declarer has to duck  and if North returns a club followed by another heart by South, declarer needs to rise. Then he ruffs a club, crosses with a trump, ruffs another club and exits with the jack of hearts, making in much the same way as Frances could have done.

The careless declarer was Mike Eden who had a club lead and a heart switch, which he ducked. North persisted with a second club, ruffed in dummy. Now declarer drew two rounds of trumps ending in dummy before taking the diamond finesse, and then he claimed. But he had not preserved the eight of spades to get to dummy. His claim was accepted by NS  but then disputed. The TD correctly ruled one down, as it was likely that the defence would now win a trick as all they have to do is force dummy while the diamonds are blocked. "Likely" in this claim law is interpreted as a not insignificant chance. Edgar Kaplan used to think it was about a one in six chance.





Friday, 27 November 2020

Rub of the Green by Foxymoron

I had always assumed that the expression "Rub of the Green" came from snooker or golf, but a little investigation shows that it is much older. It was first used in the game of bowls. A 'rub' is any hindrance or impediment that diverts the bowl from its proper course. Some of the early 16th century references to rubs are figurative, and so we can assume that the literal term 'rub' was in use before then. Shakespeare alludes to a rub in Richard II, 1593:

Lady: Madame, wee'le play at Bowles.
Queen: 'Twill make me thinke the World is full of Rubs, And that my fortune runnes against the Byas.

Chantal and Ken did not get the rub of the green on the following hand from yesterday's Woodberry Pairs event:


Chantal opened a multi with a good suit. It had one flaw, too many points outside the suit, but this was not the reason for the bad result. North overcalled 2S, natural, and East doubled, which was "Pass or Correct". He wants to compete in hearts if partner has a weak two there. South's redouble probably should be SOS, asking his partner to bid another suit, but it was undiscussed and North passed it. Poor Ken had nowhere to go. He took his chances on trying to beat 2Sxx but all E-W could take was a heart, a club and three trump tricks. -840 and unsurprisingly no matchpoints. Sometimes you just have to take a bad result on the chin.

Wednesday, 25 November 2020

The Curious Incident by Foxymoron

"To misbid a hand is a misfortune, but to misdefend it as well looks like carelessness", might have been an Oscar Wilde quote if he played bridge. He did play cards, and would have disapproved of the current spate of online cheating episodes. "One should always play fairly when one has the winning cards" was one of his more astute observations,

On this hand, we both misbid and misdefended. We did have winning cards, but did not use them properly:


Mike and Carrie Eden were the beneficiaries. I thought I had a normal 1S overcall of a strong club, but I think showing a two-suiter would have been better. We play that one-level overcalls are natural, somewhat avant garde I know, but as Vampyr pointed out, I might only have ♠KQxx and not much else. I am vulnerable, however, and I would have raised to 4S on East's hand. Instead she made a fit-jump of 3D, and when South bid 4H, I passed as I thought I had good defence. I would still have bid 4S on the East hand - it is a thirty-point pack.

I kicked off with the king of spades, on which East showed four spades, and continued with another high spade and South ruffed, and led the ace and queen of hearts. I won, continued with another spade and South ruffed and drew the remaining trumps. East had to guess on the last of these whether to keep three diamonds and three clubs or to keep four clubs and two diamonds. She "guessed" wrong and the game came home. I was quite pleased to get 10% on the board, which shows that only 9 out of 10 cats bid and defended the hand correctly.

How should East reason? Well, Conan Doyle might say:
Gregory:  Is there any other point to which you would wish to draw my attention?
Holmes: To the curious incident of the switch to a singleton diamond at trick two.
Gregory: There was no diamond switch at trick two.
Holmes: That was the curious incident.

So, West surely has two diamonds and East should keep four clubs and the game will fail. Of course, West could have a diamond void, and South might have AJxx of diamonds and AK doubleton of clubs. Surely West would have bid Four Spades himself if that were the layout. Defeating Four Hearts would have been worth a solid 60%. Why is that? Well a couple of declarers in Four Spades ruffed the heart lead and drew trumps. Now the defence had four tricks. You need to play on diamonds before drawing all the trumps. Good to see Roly, Jenny and Gerry make the doubled game with correct technique!


Thursday, 19 November 2020

Leonardo's Robot by Foxymoron

 


Robot is drawn from an old Church Slavonic word, robota, for “servitude,” “forced labor” or “drudgery.” 1995 was the 500th anniversary of Leonardo's Robot, which was rather impressive for the time, in that it could sit up, wave its arms, and maybe even respond to Stayman. 25 years ago, bridge robots had not made that much progress, passing forcing bids and the like. Even now they do some odd things. Robot West's interpretation of Cappelletti on the following hand was systemically correct, but quaint:


In a robot tournament, West thought it was only worth one call, and chose 2S, showing spades and a minor. What else?

They are getting better though. In today's Woodberry Pairs, they came second with a solid 56%, over 10% ahead of your author. This was the first Thursday afternoon Woodberry Pairs and the event got off to a reasonable start, but we could do with some more tables, so why not give it a try? It is every Thursday at 3 pm and there is always a human host. Stefanie and I are happy to play with anyone who does not have a partner. 

Robot East played this hand far too well today:


I led a normal spade, and Robot East won the trick and finessed the queen of hearts, the right percentage line in the suit. I guess it knows all those by now. It then finessed the diamond, and ran the jack of hearts, pinning North's ten. It now repeated the diamond finesse, cashed the nine of hearts, the ace of diamonds, the remaining hearts and the two other spades ending in dummy. North was squeezed in clubs and diamonds, and did her best by discarding a club, playing me for the jack, but to no avail. I suspect it just played off its winners and stumbled into the squeeze. No doubt, when the Robots learn self-kibitizing, they will be even stronger, bidding and making 6NT with an overtrick. Of course a leading Italian World Champion would find the opening club lead to break up the club-diamond squeeze and get a top for conceding only 6NT=. Different game nowadays ...










Wednesday, 18 November 2020

The Dentist Coup by Foxymoron

 Anybody looking at the auction below would think that West showed touching faith in his partner's declarer play, but the truth is that 2NT showed g22-24. When I plugged the East hand in to K-R, it spat out 23.15, so I have to give Vampyr credit for good judgement there. We split the range so that we can distinguish bad hands with 20-22 from those that are worth game!


West decided to look for a 5-3 major-suit fit with 5-card puppet Stayman and East showed a four-card major with 3D. West closed proceedings with 3NT and South led the six of hearts. Stefanie won and played a club to the eight, won by North's ten, and a second heart came back. Now East led the king of clubs and South was caught in a dentist coup. If he ducked, declarer can cash the major suit winners and exit with a third club and South is toast, as he either resurrects dummy or gives declarer TWO diamond tricks. If, in the ending, South leads the jack of diamonds, East ducks! In practice South won the second club and exited with another heart, but this just cost the overtrick as declarer unblocked the spades and enjoyed the winning clubs, for 90% of the matchpoints. Ironically, Phil Mattacks and Ken Rolph would have won if they had just saved the overtrick.

The Dentist Coup featured in several books in the 1970s and is a legal play, unlike the Alcatraz Coup, where declarer retracts his revoke having discovered the location of a key card. One I came across recently is the Superglue Coup, related to me by John Probst, a founder member of the Woodberry Bridge Club and doing pretty well despite a couple of strokes. Declarer is playing an ambitious 7H with QJT98 opposite A7654 in dummy and leads the queen, but the next player follows with both the 3 and the 2 at the same time, as though they are superglued together. Now the declarer, knowing the odds, rises with the ace, but the next player shows out. Charlie the Chimp, of course, has the K32.